Monday, September 14, 2009

The Nature of History

Who is it that said, "History is just one damned thing after another"?


&&&

The dynamic evidence page

Sunday, September 13, 2009

The Doofus Argument for Universal Health Care

I favor universal health care. (Really! Truly!)



However, I do not favor the doofus argument for health care.



If I understand it correctly, the doofus argument runs this way:

Able: We should reduce health care costs.

Baker: All things being equal, that's a good idea.

Able: Well, therefore, we should extend affordable health care to 30-45 million who can't afford regular health care now.

Baker: That's a good idea. But that will cost money, won't it? So that won't reduce health care costs, will it?.

Able: Yes, it will.

Baker: How so?

Able: Well, we'll pay for the health care for the 30-45 million by reducing the amount spent on everyone else.

Baker: I see. But couldn't we do that without extending ordinary health care to the 30-45 million people?

Able: No.

Baker: Why not?

Able: Because to reduce health care costs and give the 30-45 million people affordable health care, we will have a government-subsidized health care program. That will drive down health care costs for everyone.

Baker: I see, I think. But, Able, I have a question.

Able: Yes? What is it?

Baker: Couldn't we have a government-subsidized health care program without extending it to the 30-45 million?

Able: Baker, I lose patience with you; you're such a dimwit. The answer is, "Obviously not. Excuse me. Now I have to get to get to work at saving Medicare."



&&&

The dynamic evidence page